Why melanie amaro will win

While on a conference call with reporters, Amaro revealed she wouldn't have won the competition if L. Reid , Nicole Scherzinger or Paula Abdul had been her mentor. Still, we had to know: Has she ever forgiven Cowell for originally sending her home? When asked if she believed she could've won the competition with one of the other judges as her mentor, Amaro quickly answers, "No. I don't think I would've gone very far at all because I needed Simon to be that tough judge that he was with me in order for me to grow, to get to a higher place.

For me, I needed Simon. Though he didn't realize it at first when he sent her home from the competition in the final cut before live shows, Cowell needed Amaro as well, which is why he went to her house to invite her back into the competition two weeks after cutting her.

Many viewers have wondered if Cowell made a genuine mistake or cut Amaro to create drama. Though she doesn't know the answer to that question, Amaro doesn't care. Skip to Main Content Skip to Search. News Corp is a global, diversified media and information services company focused on creating and distributing authoritative and engaging content and other products and services. Dow Jones.

By Todd Gilchrist. To Read the Full Story. Subscribe Sign In. Well, despite her win, it appears as if Melani Amaro's career was put on hold after fans noticed that nothing really came about following her win. It turns out, Melanie Amaro was allegedly asked to go through a pop star boot camp, where she was pressured to drop weight before she could release her album.

Uh, come again? Melanie went on to make it clear that she would be releasing an album with or without Syco and Epic Records' help , however, Truly , the title of her debut album, which was set to release in , has yet to see the light of day. Luckily for Melanie, that hasn't stopped her from continuing her efforts in music.

The singer has gained quite a decent following on Instagram and YouTube, where she continues to post originals and covers of some of our favorite songs. In , Melanie moved over to Atlanta, where she joined a completely new management team following conflict with her original team. Her move over to Atlanta was a great decision, considering she has now signed with an up-and-coming label, Indie label Moorehouse Music Group. As Melanie continues to create new music, she has also taken on motherhood.